OpenAI’s structure left Sam Altman vulnerable. Now he’s out

[ad_1]

  • OpenAI’s unusual company structure weakened Sam Altman’s position as CEO and left him open to surprise on Friday when he was quickly ousted from the company.
  • The structure of the company helps explain how he was left in a vulnerable position that, as he said on Saturday, left him feeling “a little screwed.”

Sam Altman, CEO of ChatGPT maker OpenAI, arrives for a bipartisan Artificial Intelligence (AI) Insight Forum for all U.S. senators hosted by Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY) at the U.S. Capitol in Washington, U.S., September 13, 2023. 

Leah Millis | Reuters

OpenAI’s unusual company structure weakened Sam Altman’s position as CEO and left him open to surprise on Friday when he was quickly ousted from the company.

It’s rare to see founders forced out of a firm they helped co-found. At Uber, for example, founder Travis Kalanick was forced out only after a series of reports on privacy issues and allegations of discrimination and sexual harassment at the ride-sharing company. 

But Altman and co-founder Greg Brockman, who also left OpenAI Friday, didn’t have the power that Kalanick had.

“I have no equity in OpenAI,” Altman said in a May Senate hearing on A.I. Senator John Kennedy’s reaction offered some foreshadowing.

“You need a lawyer or an agent,” Kennedy said in a now-prescient joke.

The structure of the company helps explain how he was left in a vulnerable position that, as he said on Saturday, left him feeling “a little screwed.”

The easiest way to think of OpenAI’s structure is to picture a waterfall. The board of directors sits at the top. OpenAI Global, the capped-profit company in which Microsoft invested billions and of which Sam Altman had become the global face, sits at the bottom. There’s some stuff in the middle.

So let’s start at the very top of the waterfall. OpenAI’s board of directors – the ultimate decision body and the group responsible for pushing Altman out – controls OpenAI’s 501(c)(3) charity, OpenAI Inc. That charity is the nonprofit of which you may be aware. It was established to “ensure that safe artificial general intelligence is developed and benefits all of humanity.”

The company’s website says the nonprofit’s charter takes “precedence over any obligation to generate a profit.” In other words, the nonprofit is the priority, while the capped-profit Open AI Global subsidiary is not.

There’s a holding company and another LLC called OpenAI GP, which both give the board ownership or control over OpenAI Global. Again, that’s the company Microsoft invested in. It’s the one you hear about in the news when Altman talks about ChatGPT developments and whatnot. What’s important here is that OpenAI Global had no control. It was the one controlled or owned by all of the other entities in various ways.

So now you’re probably wondering — why have a for-profit company at the bottom of a corporate structure if everything’s just going to be run by a nonprofit? There’s a reason for that, too.

OpenAI added its capped profit OpenAI Global subsidiary in 2019. The shift was prompted by several things, including a desire to attract top employees and investors with “startup-like equity.”

Remember, if your ultimate goal is to ensure the safe use of AI, you’re going to want to bring on some really smart people. And that’s tough when every big company on the market is willing to pay them top dollar to work. So if you’re OpenAI, you need incentives.

Part of that shift to a for-profit model meant reassessing how OpenAI rewarded those employees and investors who gambled on the company. The company settled on a capped-profit approach. It limited the “multiple” that investors could make by sending cash OpenAI’s way.

At the time, the profit cap was set at 100x of a first-round backer’s investment. In plain language, if investors put in $1, even if OpenAI was making billions of dollars in profit, that investor would be limited to $100 in total direct profit. It would still be a sizeable return, but not unlimited.

But remember, the core mission of the nonprofit is to control the development of artificial general intelligence. And all investors and employees are subject to that mission above anything else, including the for-profit company.

OK, so we have a nonprofit with a business that makes profits in order to attract top talent. How does Altman fit in here and how’d he get ousted?

Altman had a board seat and was the best-known OpenAI personality. Aside from a small investment through a YCombinator fund (Altman was formerly its president), he doesn’t have any equity in the company. And that meant he didn’t have much control if anything turned against him.

He even joked about it Friday evening: “If I start going off, the OpenAI board should go after me for the full value of my shares.”

In fact, it reportedly worried some investors that Altman didn’t have ownership in the company he helped co-found, despite Altman’s public pronouncements that he was committed to OpenAI because he loved the work.

Most founders at later-stage companies take advantage of a dual-class share structure. Two tiers of shares are created — a set of shares for venture investors and the general public, if the company makes it to an IPO, and a more powerful set of shares reserved for founders or, in some cases, major investors.

CEOs and founders use dual-class share structures to protect themselves from losing control of their company. The rights assigned to these shareholders vary, but they often include outsize voting power, guaranteed board seats, or other governance provisions that make it hard for a board to topple them even if a company goes public. Some companies, like Google, even have three classes of shares, for its founders, employees, and investors.

Altman didn’t have those protections. Brockman, the former OpenAI president, said that Altman found out he was “being fired” in a virtual meeting Friday noon. Altman’s only heads up, Brockman said on X, the social media platform formerly known as Twitter, was a text from OpenAI chief scientist Ilya Sutskever a day before.

Investors like to back visionary founders. Some, like Peter Thiel’s Founders Fund, have centered their investment theses around the idea. Not having equity in the company could have been perceived as reducing Altman’s “skin in the game,” so to speak. But it also meant that Altman, lacking those protections, was open to a boardroom coup.

At Uber, five major investors demanded Kalanick’s departure immediately, including one of the company’s largest shareholders Benchmark, after months of negative reports on workplace culture and other controversies. OpenAI, by contrast, hasn’t seen a similar storyline emerge. Altman is a divisive figure, and many critics have worried about the impact OpenAI’s ultimate goal — artificial general intelligence, or AGI — would have for humanity. 

OpenAI’s small board lacks the experience that would be expected from a company of its size and importance. None of its largest backers, not even Microsoft, have board seats. Until Altman and Brockman’s departure, it was composed of three outside directors and three OpenAI executives. 

Brockman wasn’t involved in Altman’s firing, meaning that every outside director and Sutskever would have had to all vote to fire Altman. With no allies on the six-person board, it was a mathematical impossibility that Altman could win. 

It isn’t clear what comes next for Altman or OpenAI. Litigation is possible, given the apparently swift nature of his departure. Some of Silicon Valley’s most influential law firms have represented OpenAI or its investors in various deals, and any courthouse proceedings will likely be closely watched.



[ad_2]

Source link

Loading

87 thoughts on “OpenAI’s structure left Sam Altman vulnerable. Now he’s out

  1. К нам обращаются тысячи частных заказчиков, а брендированные подарки заказывают известные компании сувениры, широкий, тщательно подобранный ассортимент обеспечивает нам не менее широкую покупательскую аудиторию.

  2. К нам обращаются тысячи частных заказчиков, а брендированные подарки заказывают известные компании подарки, широкий, тщательно подобранный ассортимент обеспечивает нам не менее широкую покупательскую аудиторию.

  3. К нам обращаются тысячи частных заказчиков, а брендированные подарки заказывают известные компании матрёшки, широкий, тщательно подобранный ассортимент обеспечивает нам не менее широкую покупательскую аудиторию.

  4. Excellent piece! 👏 The information is presented in a compelling manner. Adding more visuals in your future articles could make them even more enjoyable for readers. 📷

  5. This article is amazing! The way it describes things is truly engaging and incredibly effortless to follow. It’s obvious that a lot of work and research went into this, which is really commendable. The author has managed to make the theme not only interesting but also enjoyable to read. I’m enthusiastically excited about exploring more information like this in the upcoming. Thanks for sharing, you’re doing an remarkable work!

  6. 🌌 Wow, blog ini seperti petualangan fantastis melayang ke galaksi dari kemungkinan tak terbatas! 🌌 Konten yang mengagumkan di sini adalah perjalanan rollercoaster yang mendebarkan bagi pikiran, memicu kegembiraan setiap saat. 💫 Baik itu gayahidup, blog ini adalah sumber wawasan yang inspiratif! #PetualanganMenanti 🚀 ke dalam perjalanan kosmik ini dari pengetahuan dan biarkan pemikiran Anda melayang! ✨ Jangan hanya menikmati, alami sensasi ini! #MelampauiBiasa 🚀 akan bersyukur untuk perjalanan mendebarkan ini melalui alam keajaiban yang tak berujung! ✨

  7. 🚀 Wow, this blog is like a fantastic adventure blasting off into the universe of endless possibilities! 🌌 The captivating content here is a rollercoaster ride for the imagination, sparking awe at every turn. 🎢 Whether it’s inspiration, this blog is a goldmine of inspiring insights! #MindBlown 🚀 into this exciting adventure of imagination and let your imagination roam! 🌈 Don’t just read, immerse yourself in the thrill! 🌈 🚀 will be grateful for this thrilling joyride through the worlds of endless wonder! 🌍

  8. 💫 Wow, this blog is like a rocket soaring into the galaxy of excitement! 💫 The captivating content here is a thrilling for the mind, sparking curiosity at every turn. 🎢 Whether it’s inspiration, this blog is a treasure trove of exciting insights! 🌟 Embark into this exciting adventure of discovery and let your mind soar! 🌈 Don’t just enjoy, savor the thrill! 🌈 🚀 will thank you for this thrilling joyride through the worlds of awe! 🚀

  9. I urge you steer clear of this platform. My personal experience with it was purely dismay as well as doubts about scamming practices. Be extremely cautious, or alternatively, seek out a more reputable service to fulfill your requirements.

  10. I highly advise stay away from this platform. My personal experience with it was only disappointment and doubts about scamming practices. Be extremely cautious, or alternatively, seek out a trustworthy site to meet your needs.

  11. I strongly recommend to avoid this site. My personal experience with it has been only disappointment along with suspicion of fraudulent activities. Be extremely cautious, or better yet, find an honest service to meet your needs.

  12. I urge you stay away from this platform. My own encounter with it was only disappointment and concerns regarding deceptive behavior. Proceed with extreme caution, or even better, seek out a trustworthy platform to fulfill your requirements.

  13. I strongly recommend stay away from this site. My personal experience with it has been nothing but frustration and concerns regarding deceptive behavior. Proceed with extreme caution, or alternatively, seek out an honest platform for your needs.

  14. I urge you stay away from this platform. The experience I had with it has been nothing but frustration as well as concerns regarding fraudulent activities. Be extremely cautious, or better yet, seek out an honest platform for your needs.I urge you to avoid this platform. The experience I had with it has been nothing but disappointment along with doubts about scamming practices. Exercise extreme caution, or alternatively, find an honest platform for your needs.

  15. I urge you stay away from this site. My own encounter with it has been purely disappointment and doubts about fraudulent activities. Exercise extreme caution, or alternatively, seek out an honest service for your needs.

  16. I urge you to avoid this site. My personal experience with it was nothing but frustration along with doubts about scamming practices. Exercise extreme caution, or even better, look for an honest site to fulfill your requirements.

  17. I highly advise to avoid this platform. My own encounter with it has been purely dismay as well as suspicion of scamming practices. Be extremely cautious, or even better, seek out a more reputable site to fulfill your requirements.

  18. I strongly recommend steer clear of this platform. My personal experience with it has been purely frustration as well as suspicion of scamming practices. Be extremely cautious, or alternatively, look for a trustworthy site for your needs.

  19. I urge you to avoid this site. My personal experience with it has been purely frustration and concerns regarding deceptive behavior. Be extremely cautious, or alternatively, seek out a trustworthy site to fulfill your requirements.

  20. I highly advise steer clear of this site. The experience I had with it has been purely frustration along with doubts about deceptive behavior. Exercise extreme caution, or alternatively, find an honest site for your needs.

  21. I strongly recommend stay away from this site. My own encounter with it has been only dismay as well as doubts about deceptive behavior. Exercise extreme caution, or alternatively, seek out a trustworthy service to meet your needs.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *